An eye on auxiliary damage

Claims for auxiliary engine damage cost an average of US$344,615 Claims for auxiliary engine damage cost an average of US$344,615

A new report from insurance company The Swedish Club, placing the blame for most auxiliary engines on poor maintenance, gives an insight into why owners might look to swap gensets for batteries.

“Imagine picking your car up from the workshop after regular maintenance. On your way home there is a loud noise from the engine and the car comes to a shrieking halt. You open the hood to see the engine has failed catastrophically, with bits and pieces from liners and pistons scattered all around.”

According to The Swedish Club, that is what happens in more than half of all auxiliary engine failures. The insurer investigated seven years of claims across nearly 3,000 ships to come up with some worrying insights. Chief among those is the finding that 55% of all incidences of auxiliary engine failure occur within 1,000 hours of overhaul – within 10% of time between overhaul (TBO) given that typical TBOs are 12,000-16,000 hours.

Auxiliary engine failures are a common cause of insurance claims. They occur, on average, on one of every 100 vessels each year, representing 7% of hull and machinery claims and 16% of machinery claims. Container vessels have a significantly higher claims frequency due to the larger number of installed engines on these vessels. In addition, these engines have considerable output, hence the repair cost is greater compared with other vessels

Although they are by no means the most expensive of machinery claims, an average cost of over US$344,000 makes them are a significant contributor to premiums. This expense is even more unpalatable given that mistakes on the part of crew are a prime cause of damage. The club records that the common factor in most cases is the ‘incorrect assembly of vital engine parts in connection with regular overhaul’. In particular, the assembly of connecting rods, bearings and pistons cause severe and costly accidents (see box).

Non-adherence to procedures, lack of training and experience are major factors. A connecting rod assembly, for example, is a critical and highly stressed joint and must be re-assembled exactly in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions with proper tools. Special hydraulic tools used for engine assembly need to be calibrated and carefully checked before use.

The club reports seeing insufficient understanding of the importance of these procedures ‘all too often’. The manager has the responsibility to ensure that crew are competent to undertake such repairs. Crew should either be trained on the specific engine types, the study explains, or an expert from the manufacturer should be engaged to attend the overhaul.

THE EVIL OIL

Poor lubrication oil management is in many cases the predominating factor for an auxiliary engine breakdown, the club reports.

Auxiliary engines are four-stroke engines and as such the engine oil is used for cooling of pistons crowns and lubrication of parts including cylinder liners and bearings. There is a risk that the lube oil will be contaminated with soot and combustion particles, especially if the engine has accumulated some running hours.

Proper lubrication oil management is critical for minimising the risk of engine failures. This is essential when operating the engine on heavy fuel oil (HFO). The lubrication oil must be analysed at regular intervals. Detection of water, soot particles and metal particles will serve as an early warning for engine problems. The authors caution that negative results from oil analysis must be investigated and addressed promptly.

“Whilst prevention is always better than cure, steps can be taken to mitigate the damage caused by the failure of the auxiliary engine,” the report concludes. Most modern auxiliary engine installations can be started and stopped remotely from the engine control room. But it is good practice to be present at the engine when starting, especially after longer periods of still-stand and after overhaul. If someone is present at the engine there is at least a possibility to intervene and shut down the engine manually.

Causes of damage

The Swedish Club identified four major causes of auxiliary engine damage:

Connecting rod bolts (58 cases):

  • Improper tightening of bolts;
  • Hydraulic tool/pump not calibrated;
  • Lack of crew training and adherence to procedures.

Contamination of lubrication oil (27 cases):

  • Improper lube oil management;
  • Lube oil filters degraded over time;
  • Introduction of dirt (rags) during maintenance;
  • Damage/leaking lube oil cooling water heat exchanger.

Incorrect maintenance & procedures (25 cases):

  • Incorrect adjustment of valve clearance;
  • Installed pistons in wrong directions;
  • Installed wrong type of plungers in fuel pumps;
  • Mixed up inlet and outlet valves during overhaul;
  • Not following manufacturer’s service letter regarding required modifications;
  • Not installing correct bearings following crankshaft grinding.

Overspeed (16 cases):

  • Overspeed trips not in working condition;
  • Wrong assembly after exchange of governor;
  • Wrong assembly of fuel linkage;
  • Worn out drive system for governor.

The Swedish Club machinery claims by type, 2010-2016

    

Claims Type

Number of claims

Cost (US$)

Average cost (US$)

Main engine

313

180,364,796

576,245

Propulsion*

244

109,613,532

449,236

Auxiliary engine

192

66,166,087

344,615

Turbocharger

134

40,850,539

304,855

Steering gear

48

20,165,111

420,106

Boiler, auxiliary boiler

50

16,901,509

338,030

Crane

66

16,417,241

248,746

Electrical, engine room automation

47

10,899,178

231,897

Cargo gear and equipment, cargo heating

16

7,463,057

466,441

Deck equipment, other

23

4,180,816

181,775

Stern tube

6

1,844,055

307,343

Other**

58

16,444,440

283,525

Total

1,197

491,310,361

319,447

    

Note: *Propeller, shaft, gearbox; **Machinery and equipment for lifesaving, navigation, thruster, etc.

Source: The Swedish Club, 'Auxiliary Engine Damage', 2018

LATEST PRESS RELEASES

Oil quality is the key to increased up-time

Research has shown that 80% of all hydraulic failures can be directly attributed to oil contaminatio... Read more

Auramarine appointed as preferred fuel system service provider for entire MARCAS-served fleet

Turku, Finland, 09.10.2018. Auramarine, the leading provider of engine room fuel supply and auxiliar... Read more

Great anniversary year – 60 years of Geislinger & 25 years of “Gesilco®“

Geislinger GmbH, located in Salzburg, Austria, celebrates its 60th anniversary this year which coinc... Read more

MYTASKIT NAMES PACSOFT FIRST INTERNATIONAL RESELLER

Expanding its global presence, MyTaskit has signed its first international reseller. Auckland, New Z... Read more

Vickers Oils are pleased to welcome Ian Bower, Business Development Manager and Esther Murray

Vickers Oils are pleased to welcome Ian Bower, Business Development Manager and Esther Murray, Marke... Read more

SHAFT VIBRATION ELIMINATED WITH VESCONITE HILUBE

After replacing the all-rubber cutlass bearing of his new Jeanneau Sun Fast 35 Tide The Knot a frust... Read more

View all